Skip navigation

Windows IT Pro UPDATE--The Great Internet Explorer Debate Continues--November 23, 2004

This email newsletter comes to you free and is supported by the following advertisers, which offer products and services in which you might be interested. Please take a moment to visit these advertiser's Web sites and show your support for Windows IT Pro UPDATE.

Bulletproof Your Windows Network with Group Policy

Free White Paper: Measuring the ROI of Systems Management Software


1. Commentary
- The Great Internet Explorer Debate Continues

2. Hot Off the Press
- Microsoft Releases Avalon Technology Preview for Windows Server 2003, Windows XP

3. Resources
- Featured Thread: Is Firefox better or just untested?
- How can I view the state of Active Directory (AD) permissions delegations?

4. New and Improved
- Recover Deleted AD Objects

==== Sponsor: Bulletproof Your Windows Network with Group Policy ====
Bulletproof your Windows network with Group Policy. Take full advantage of this complex, powerful technology. Authored by industry expert and Quest Chief Technology Officer, Darren Mar-Elia, this white paper simplifies the complexities of Group Policy and covers a wide array of key topics such as; architecture and function of Group Policy, how to optimize Group Policy to fortify the security and usability of your environment and best practices to ensure consistent, expected application of policy. Check out this free white paper titled: "Bulletproof Your Windows Network with Group Policy."


==== 1. Commentary: The Great Internet Explorer Debate Continues ====
by Paul Thurrott, News Editor, [email protected]

Last week, I discussed Microsoft's recent attempts to promote Microsoft Internet Explorer (IE), a product I consider among the most ill-conceived software products of all time. However, based on the feedback I received from numerous Windows IT Pro UPDATE readers, I'm in the minority, at least when it comes to business use of Web browsers. And although alternative Web browsers such as Mozilla's Firefox seem to fare better with tech-savvy individuals and power users, it's unclear to me whether that use will ever translate into dominant market share.

Recently, Microsoft Director of Windows Product Management Gary Schare told me that compatibility with existing Web sites was one of the huge draws of IE, and that opinion was borne out in the feedback I received. Overwhelmingly, readers speaking on behalf of companies said that they would be sticking with IE.

IE's compatibility prowess can be seen in various ways. First, the core HTML that many sites use is designed with IE in mind; often Web developers don't even test the code on other browsers. Second, IE, unlike Firefox, supports ActiveX technologies that many sites use. Third, some plug-ins and other browser add-ons are available only on IE. And finally, many customers require interoperability with Microsoft technologies such as Windows SharePoint Services (WSS) and Microsoft Outlook Web Access (OWA). Although you can run OWA on Firefox, the experience is much better in IE and very close to that you get with Outlook.

Although the reasons these Microsoft technologies work best (or at all) with IE are largely related to the first two points, program interoperability is worth mentioning separately because many readers manage networks at Microsoft shops. One such reader, Randy Barger, said "Interoperability is key. Many of my customers use ... Web-based applications. If I switched customers to another browser, they would, at the very least, have a diminished feature set available to them within these applications."

Some readers also noted that security was a concern and that, oddly enough, IE made the grade. Though IE has an admittedly spotty record, the product has undergone Microsoft Trustworthy Computing code reviews and been overhauled dramatically in both Windows Server 2003 and Windows XP Service Pack 2 (SP2). "Security is a huge concern and in the corporate world that is next to cost," reader Tom Krause said. "\[With Mozilla,\] where's the track record? Where's the support?"

Reader Scott Barker also brought up an excellent point. "Unlike IE, which can be automatically 'patched' through Windows Update, Firefox requires a manual reinstall when updates or patches are released," he wrote. "As you know, most machines (especially those with XP SP2 installed) are set up to automatically run \[Automatic Updates\] and as a consequence, IE patches get installed automatically. But not ... Firefox. Yes, Firefox is a great browser, but how do you automate deployment of patches or updates when they happen? It adds yet more complexity to managing your environment."

Even end users who voiced their support for Firefox--and I'd have to put myself in this category--generally admitted that Firefox has problems. Many sites--especially online banking sites--don't work in non-IE browsers. That hasn't stopped a large population of influential people from installing and migrating to Firefox, but these sorts of incompatibilities are a nightmare for IT departments that have to support many users. Whether you want to call it inertia or pragmatism, most companies simply aren't going to be switching any time soon.

Schare also had an interesting response to a comment I made about IE's stagnant development and the fact that Firefox is supported by a vibrant community of enthusiasts who are extending the product's reach with new add-ons every day. He noted that IE, too, benefits from such a community and that users who want any of Firefox's features--such as tabbed browsing--can simply download add-ons or other IE-based browsers to get that functionality. "Right now, those kinds of features are more for advanced users and early adopters," he said. When I asked him when we might see such functionality in IE, Schare told me that it would happen in the Longhorn release of IE. Right now, the IE team has no plans to release any IE add-ons or improvements before Longhorn, although that could change. Schare noted that the MSN team was leveraging IE's add-on mechanisms by releasing such add-ons as the MSN Toolbar and that the IE team might consider releasing similar updates.

Although Microsoft has improved IE's security in the XP SP2 release, that version of IE isn't available to Windows 2000 or Windows 9x users, and I think that's a mistake. That said, it's clear why most businesses won't be switching from IE any time soon, although you might argue that an upgrade from Win2K or Win9x is more complicated than migrating users from IE to Firefox, assuming there are no compatibility concerns. Like many of you, I'm forced to use IE for work-related tasks, but I'll keep using Firefox when I can. It just seems like it provides safer access to Web-based content than does IE.

Also, I'd be remiss if I didn't thank everyone who wrote in this week. As always, Windows IT Pro UPDATE readers have proven themselves to be a dedicated and well-informed bunch. Thanks so much to everyone who provided feedback for this commentary.


==== Sponsor: Free White Paper: Measuring the ROI of Systems Management Software ====
Argent delivers what a growing number of enterprises need today: flawless management of Windows, UNIX, and application servers; low total cost of ownership; flexible configuration; scalable architecture; modular products; positive ROI; and outstanding customer support. Every enterprise IT department wants value without sacrificing performance, and that describes Argent's value proposition. To read the entire paper, click here:


==== 2. Hot Off the Press ====
by Paul Thurrott, [email protected]

Microsoft Releases Avalon Technology Preview for Windows Server 2003, Windows XP
Late Friday, Microsoft quietly released to Microsoft Developer Network (MSDN) Subscriber Downloads a technology preview of the Avalon presentation technologies portion of the WinFX software development kit (SDK). The preview contains some Avalon features that Microsoft designed solely for Longhorn (the next major Windows release) but will also run on Windows Server 2003 and Windows XP. Microsoft was quick to warn developers that the release isn't a full beta version but is an early look at Avalon technology only, one that the company hopes will garner a lot of feedback. To read the complete story, visit the following URL:

==== Announcements ====
(from Windows IT Pro and its partners)

The Email Security Center is Your First Line of Defense
The Email Security Center provides valuable tools and expertise to help secure your messaging services against attacks and unsolicited email. Our experts share the latest trends, guidance, and resources for understanding and blocking spam, viruses, and attacks while saving bandwidth, conserving server capacity, and minimizing administration costs. Sign up today!

Are You a Hacker Target?
You are if you have an Internet connection faster than 384Kbps. In this free live Web seminar, Alan Sugano will examine two attacks (an SMTP Auth Attack and a SQL Attack) that let spammers get into the network and relay spam. Find out how to keep the hackers out of your network and what to do if your mail server is blacklisted as an open relay. Register now!

Enter to Win TiVo at the Windows IT Pro eNewsletter Center
Did you know Windows IT Pro has 12 free eNewsletters to help you find up-to-date fast information on the topics you care about? Sign up now for any of our eNewsletters and be entered for a chance to win a TiVo and a lifetime subscription to TiVo service.

Sarbanes Oxley: Race to the Finish Line
The deadline is looming for compliance with the final set of Sarbanes-Oxley requirements. Are you ready, or are you still struggling with Section 404 issues? In this free on-demand Web seminar, let the experts of Ernst & Young LLP and NetIQ provide you with the tips and techniques required to maintain proper internal control frameworks. Register today!

~~~~ Hot Release: (Advertisement) Find Oracle Answers Fast ~~~~
Find answers to your Oracle questions. With over 700 how-to articles and simple tips, you'll discover how to maximize Oracle features and ultimately improve IT productivity and management of your network and database. Get answers now!

==== Instant Poll ====

Results of Previous Poll
The voting has closed in Windows IT Pro's nonscientific Instant Poll for the question, "Does your company plan to switch to Mozilla's Firefox Web browser?" Here are the results from the 365 votes:
- 18% Yes, we already have switched
- 14% Yes, we plan to switch in the near future
- 15% We'll wait and see
- 53% No, we'll stick with our current browser

New Instant Poll
The next Instant Poll question is, "If your company won't be switching to an alternative to Microsoft Internet Explorer, why not?" Go to the Windows IT Pro home page and submit your vote for a) Security, b) Incompatibility and support concerns, c) Cost and effort of switching, or d) We're satisfied with IE.

==== 4. Resources ====

Featured Thread: Is Firefox better or just untested?
Read the latest post on the Firefox debate here:

Tip: How can I view the state of Active Directory (AD) permissions delegations?
by John Savill,
Find the answer at the following URL:

==== Events Central ====
(A complete Web and live events directory brought to you by Windows IT Pro: )

Token Authentication: Getting It Right
More and more companies are taking the first steps toward leaving passwords behind and implementing tokens for at least a portion of their users and systems. In this free live Web seminar, find out the advantages of implementing tokens and learn how you can you make a solid business case to management that justifies the costs. And, you'll receive checklists of key evaluation, testing points, and critical success factors for rollout time. Register now!

==== 4. New and Improved ====
by Angie Brew, [email protected]

Recover Deleted AD Objects
Quest Software released Quest Object Restore for Active Directory, a free utility that provides a GUI, similar to the Windows Recycle Bin, for viewing and restoring Active Directory (AD) objects. This graphical utility lets AD administrators take advantage of Windows Server 2003's tombstone reanimation capabilities and recover deleted objects without rebooting a domain controller (DC). You can download Quest Object Restore for Active Directory at Contact Quest Software at 949-754-8000.

Tell Us About a Hot Product and Get a T-Shirt!
Have you used a product that changed your IT experience by saving you time or easing your daily burden? Tell us about the product, and we'll send you a T-shirt if we write about the product in a future Windows IT Pro What's Hot column. Send your product suggestions with information about how the product has helped you to mailto:[email protected].


==== Contact Us ====

About the newsletter -- [email protected] About technical questions -- About product news -- [email protected] About your subscription -- [email protected] About sponsoring UPDATE -- [email protected]


This email newsletter is brought to you by Windows IT Pro, the leading publication for IT professionals deploying Windows and related technologies. Subscribe today!

View the Windows IT Pro Privacy policy at Windows IT Pro is a division of Penton Media, Inc. 221 East 29th Street, Loveland, CO 80538, Attention: Customer Service Department Copyright 2004, Penton Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.