Exchange & Outlook UPDATE, Exchange Edition--Counting Servers--December 7, 2006

-------| Exchange & Outlook UPDATE |-------

*Commentary: Counting Servers
*Exchanging Ideas: In-Place Upgrade to Exchange Server 2007?
*Industry Briefing: Free Tool Lets You Calculate Exchange TCO
*New and Improved: Brick-Level Recovery for Exchange Server



Archiving, PST Management, & Compliance Made Easy with Sherpa Software

Email Discovery and Compliance

Email Is Down: Now You're Out of Compliance!


Sponsor: Sherpa Software

Archiving, PST Management, & Compliance Made Easy with Sherpa Software

Having trouble accessing and archiving PST content? Looking for an affordable email management solution? Archive Attender and Mail Attender from Sherpa Software can centrally manage and archive data from PST files (local/network), public folders, and mailboxes.

Enforce retention policies, search and retrieve content, archive sensitive information, manage archive databases, delete unnecessary emails/attachments, compact PST files, and much more.

Whether it's discovering PST content, mailbox management, or trend reporting, our products will help fulfill your Exchange storage, management, and compliance needs. Download a FREE TRIAL today and instantly view statistics like total message/attachment count, size, and type across your entire Exchange information store!


***COMMENTARY: Counting Servers
by Paul Robichaux, Exchange Editor, [email protected]

Last week, I had the good fortune to be in Dallas to teach a class of bright, experienced sales and support engineers who work for a major software firm. They had lots of good questions about Exchange Server 2007, how it would affect their company's products, and what they needed to know to help prepare their customers for making the transition.

During the class, an interesting discussion started: Do you need more servers for Exchange 2007 than for Exchange Server 2003? On its face, this question would seem simple. However, the role and capability changes in Exchange 2007 mean that it's not actually simple at all.

Let's take the simplest case: migrating a single Exchange 2003 server to Exchange 2007. You can do a one-to-one replacement of that server with an Exchange 2007 server, and—poof!—you're done. You'll need to install the Hub Transport, Mailbox, and Client Access server roles on your single server (as well as the Unified Messaging—UM—role, if you want to use it). This type of installation is well supported and, in my experience, has worked well during the beta period. In this case, you don't need more servers than you would for Exchange 2003.

The next case is a more complex migration involving one or more front-end servers talking to one or more back-end mailbox servers. Just like the single-server case, this scenario allows for one-to-one replacement. Your front-end servers would be replaced by one or more Client Access servers, and the mailbox servers would be replaced by servers with the Mailbox role. However, because Exchange 2007 scales significantly better on the same hardware than Exchange 2003 does, you might be able to reduce the number of servers you use. HP's initial test data shows a large reduction in the I/O requirements for hardware that moves from Exchange 2003 to Exchange 2007, with further reductions in I/O operations per second (IOPS) if you move from 4GB to 8GB of memory.

Probably the most complex migration involves clustering. In Exchange 2003, you can have multiple-node clusters that handle the mailbox role; front-end servers are supposed to be made redundant through Network Load Balancing (NLB). In Exchange 2007, only the Mailbox server role can be clustered. Microsoft recommends using other technologies (including NLB) for the Client Access, UM, Edge Transport, and Hub Transport roles. If you can't cluster these roles on an Exchange 2007 system, how many servers do you need to replicate a two-node Exchange 2003 cluster?

The answer is what you might expect: You'd need two servers to replace the clustered mailbox server, plus an additional server for the Client Access and Hub Transport roles. If you wanted to add redundancy for the Client Access and Hub Transport roles, you'd need an additional server. So, to duplicate the functionality of the two-node Exchange 2003 cluster, you would indeed need more servers with Exchange 2007 (which, of course, means you'd need more Windows and Exchange licenses).

However, there are three mitigating factors to the cluster scenario. First, most Exchange administrators won't be affected because they're not currently using Exchange 2003 in clusters. Second, the local and clustered continuous replication (CCR) features in Exchange 2007 might counteract your need to use a conventional cluster (which Exchange 2007 calls a single copy cluster). Finally, clustering improvements in Exchange 2007 mean that you might not need the expensive shared storage required for Exchange 2003 clusters; therefore, your overall cost of upgrading a cluster might be lower than it would have been to deploy originally. This won't be true in all cases, but I suspect that organizations that bought SANs to use solely with their clusters might find some surprising cost benefits from ditching shared storage and using CCR instead.

Now, to a completely different subject: We've finalized the sessions and speakers for the spring 2007 Exchange Connections show. One new feature I'm really excited about is a track for vendor presentations. We're offering Exchange-related ISVs a chance to present deeply technical sessions to attendees—with no marketing fluff! We'll also have panel discussions featuring multiple vendors in a given topic area. If your company is interested in presenting, please send a session proposal to [email protected] If you're interested in hearing from a particular vendor or want to know more about a particular technology, drop me a note to let me know what you'd like to see!


Sponsor: CA

Email Discovery and Compliance
You know you need to manage your email data; how do you do it? What steps are you taking? What additional measures should you enact? What shouldn't you do? Get answers to these questions and get control of your vital messaging data. Download the free eBook today!



Focus: In-Place Upgrade to Exchange Server 2007?

Will there be an in-place upgrade solution for Microsoft Exchange Server 2003 to Exchange Server 2007? John Savill answers this question for you.

Have a question? Got answers? Join your peers in the Exchange discussion forums:
Current Threads:
Resource Scheduling and Public Folders
How to Query and Export a List of Email Address?
Cannot Add Additional Mailbox to a MAPI Profile

Don't forget to sound off in our Instant Poll. This month's question is "What tool do you currently use to assist in Exchange capacity planning?"

~~~~ Hot Spot: ~~~~

Email Is Down: Now You're Out of Compliance!
When your email systems go down, do your employees stop communicating? Of course not—they find alternate methods, which may not be compliant with your messaging regulations. Download this free Executive Guide to discover the impact of email outages on compliance and learn methods for establishing continuity in your corporate messaging environment.


***Industry Briefing

Free Tool Lets You Calculate Exchange TCO
by Anne Grubb, [email protected]

The release of Exchange Server 2007 looms large, and migration is on the minds of many Exchange administrators. But before you can even start to plan a migration, you need a key piece of information: how much migration will cost. Azaleos, a provider of managed email solutions, is providing a free tool to make that task easier.

"Many customers don't have good understanding of how much they're spending on running their email environment," says Azaleos CTO Keith McCall. To address what it perceived as IT pros' need for accurate Exchange total cost of ownership (TCO) information, Azaleos commissioned Osterman Research to develop the tool, called Microsoft Exchange Cost Calculator, by using cost and configuration data from Azaleos's customers. Azaleos offers two versions of the tool: a simple version, which you can access directly on Azaleos's Web site, and a richer-featured version, also free, which you can obtain by filling out a contact form.

In keeping with Azaleos's "email as a utility mantra," says McCall, the Exchange Cost Calculator resembles a tool that some utility companies provide to help you project your energy costs. "The tool breaks down the components of migration. It asks you questions such as what's your migration timeline and calculates items such as the costs of a hardware refresh \[i.e. that you'll need for the migration\] and growth of storage over time," he says. The full version of the calculator is a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet, and users can view the macros and formulas used in the TCO calculations. To obtain the Exchange Cost Calculator, go to


by Blake Eno, [email protected]

Brick-Level Recovery for Exchange Server
Mendocino Software announced Exchange Module for InfiniView, an enterprise recovery solution for Exchange Server that allows Exchange recovery from any previous point in time. The software can recover an entire Exchange environment or provide brick-level recovery at the message, mailbox, calendar, folder, and task level. Exchange Module for InfiniView doesn't affect the Exchange environment in production and provides keyword-based search functionality that offloads content search of Exchange systems. The software also integrates with Volume Shadow Copy Service (VSS). For more information, contact Mendocino Software at 510-668-1600.

Wanted: your reviews of products you've tested and used in production. Share your experiences and ratings of products to "[email protected]" and get a Best Buy gift certificate.



These Windows-related events, papers, and resources will help you keep your knowledge and skills up to date and help you deploy, secure, and maintain the latest Exchange- and Windows-related technologies. For more Exchange related resources, visit

Are you an Oracle professional who has cross-platform responsibilities, or do you need to transfer your skill set to SQL Server? If so, register for the free Cross Platform Data online event, January 30 and 31 and February 1, 2007. In a seminar featuring SQL Server and Oracle experts Andrew Sisson from Scalability Experts and Douglas McDowell from Solid Quality Learning, you'll learn key concepts about SQL Server 2005, including how to deploy SQL Server's BI capabilities on Oracle, proof points demonstrating that SQL Server is enterprise-ready, and how to successfully deploy Oracle on the Windows platform.

Are you who you say you are? Really? Even on Linux? Really? If you're like most IT professionals, this type of identity crisis is a plague. Virtual TechX World—available December 14—makes your life (and the lives of your users) easier by equipping you with the latest interoperability insights and technology. Slots are filling quickly—register today!

Your business, like most today, relies on its computing systems to store financial information, house proprietary data, and maintain communications channels. This increasing reliance also increases the dangers to your systems from security breaches, including viruses, spyware, spam, and hackers. Visit the Windows Protection Site for the latest tips on safeguarding your system.

Branch offices need flexibility and autonomy in implementing IT solutions; corporate requirements require centralized management, security, and compliance initiatives. Learn to resolve these conflicts and reduce your operational costs for branch offices with limited IT resources. Download the free whitepaper today!

Is your company addressing the risks of email without diluting the benefits of email? In this free white paper, discover the ROI associated with deployment of an email archiving solution. You'll learn that total potential return requires a full-featured message management system that addresses all the enterprise cost centers surrounding email. Download this guide today and find out what you can do to realize the dramatic and quantifiable ROI that will move your company quickly from analyzing options and seeking budget approval to solving the problem with a solution that will pay for itself many times over.



Securing multiple domains or host names? Learn how the Starter PKI program can save time, reduce costs, and provide you with a multiple digital certificate account.
BONUS: Register for any white paper from Windows IT Pro in the month of December, and be entered to win a Wii! Visit for more information and a complete white paper listing.



Uncover Essential Windows Knowledge Through Excavator
Try out the ultimate vertical search tool—Windows Excavator. Windows Excavator gives you fast, thorough, third-party information while filtering out unwanted content. Visit today!

Vote for the Next "IT Pro of the Month!"
Your vote counts! Take the time to reward excellence in an IT pro who deserves it. The first 100 readers to cast a vote will receive a one-year subscription to Windows IT Pro, compliments of Microsoft. Voting takes only a few seconds, so don't miss out. Cast your vote now:

~~~~ Contact Us ~~~~

About the newsletter -- [email protected]
About technical questions --
About product news -- [email protected]
About your subscription -- [email protected]
About sponsoring UPDATE -- [email protected]


This email newsletter is brought to you by Exchange & Outlook Administrator, the leading publication for IT professionals managing, securing, optimizing, and migrating Exchange and Outlook. Subscribe today!

View the Windows IT Pro Privacy policy at

Windows IT Pro a division of Penton Media Inc.
221 East 29th Street, Loveland, CO 80538,
Attention: Customer Service Department

Copyright 2006, Penton Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.