Windows IT Pro UPDATE--Linux: Looking Past the Rhetoric--November 2, 2004

This email newsletter comes to you free and is supported by the following advertisers, which offer products and services in which you might be interested. Please take a moment to visit these advertiser's Web sites and show your support for Windows IT Pro UPDATE.

White Paper! Unraveling Group Policy Problems

Free White Paper: High Availability for Windows Services


1. Commentary
- Linux: Looking Past the Rhetoric

2. Hot Off the Press
- With iPod Success, Apple Takes "Network Effect" from Microsoft

3. Resources
- Featured Thread: Win XP Starts Up Automatically
- Tip: What's the difference between the Microsoft Virtual Server 2005 editions?

4. New and Improved
- Identify and Patch Security Holes
- Test Installations Before Deployment

==== Sponsor: White Paper! Unraveling Group Policy Problems ====

The consequences of Group Policy problems can be devastating. Problems can include user's lack of access to resources, increased calls to an overwhelmed help desk and compromised data security. Avoid these consequences. Learn how to better troubleshoot Group Policy. Download Unraveling Group Policy Problems today. Authored by Windows infrastructure expert and Quest Chief Technology Officer Darren Mar-Elia, this paper delivers practical information to take on the challenges of Group Policy. This paper outlines a systematic approach to troubleshooting, identifies potential problem areas with relation to Group Policy, offers tips to support optimal logging and provides tools and techniques for diagnosis and troubleshooting. Get to the bottom of Group Policy problems with this new "Unraveling Group Policy Problems" white paper today.


==== 1. Commentary: Linux: Looking Past the Rhetoric ====
by Paul Thurrott, News Editor, [email protected]

You can tell that Microsoft is scared about something when the company can't stop talking about it. On the client side, the software giant is so nervous about the amazing advances made by Apple Computer with its iPod portable audio player and iTunes Music Store that the company recently spent hundreds of millions of dollars rejuvenating Windows XP with a variety of digital media updates that likely will prove more confusing than exciting to many consumers. On the enterprise side, long-time nemeses such as IBM and Novell have rallied around the open-source Linux standard in their latest bid to outflank Microsoft's server products. Predictably, Microsoft has come out firing.

Microsoft's public stance regarding Linux has changed a lot over the years, but its current posturing finally matches what the company has admitted privately for years: Linux is taking business away from other OSs, and it's only a matter of time before it starts eating into Microsoft's bottom line. To respond, the company's executives--especially Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer and Chief Technical Officer (CTO) Craig Mundie--have begun addressing Linux issues frankly in speeches, interviews, and meetings. And of course, Microsoft believes that its comprehensive server product portfolio--Windows Server System--is a match for anything the open-source world can offer.

The latest volley arrived last week in the form of an email ostensibly written by Ballmer (but more likely written by others and approved by Ballmer) in which he addressed IT executives about the Linux threat. Parroting many of the points the company has tried to publicize through its "Get the Facts" advertising campaign, Ballmer pointed out that Windows provides numerous advantages over Linux. Let's examine some of these advantages.

A Long-Term Cost Advantage

Open-source backers have used the "no cost" aspect of Linux as a bargaining chip for years, but the truth is far more subtle. Even if an enterprise is able to obtain a Linux OS at no cost, the true cost of such a system must include service and maintenance; Microsoft has argued that, here, the cost argument breaks down in its favor. In his email message, Ballmer touted the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) advantage of Windows over Linux, and noted that "all of the major Linux vendors and distributors (including HP, IBM, Novell \[SUSE and Ximian\], and Red Hat) have begun charging hefty premiums for must-have items such as technical service and support, product warranties, and licensing indemnification." Employee training is also more expensive with Linux, Ballmer claims.

A major enterprise that switches from Windows to Linux would experience costs three to four times greater than if the company had upgraded to the latest Windows versions, while taking three times as long to complete, according to an independent Yankee Group study. I don't think that most Linux installations are (yet) coming at the expense of Windows. However, it's equally clear that this trend can't continue if Linux is to continue growing.

Better Security

Although people might chuckle at the notion, Ballmer claims that Windows is more secure than Linux. He says that "the four \[biggest\] Linux distributions have a higher incidence and severity of vulnerabilities and are slower than Microsoft to provide security updates," and I'm sure that's true. But it's also true that the open-source Apache Web server--a product that's used by far more Web sites than is Microsoft IIS--has suffered from far fewer and less debilitating attacks than has IIS.

Open-source advocates question some of Microsoft's statistics. For example, although it's true that Windows Server suffers from fewer critical security flaws than, say, Red Hat Enterprise Linux, part of the reason is that Microsoft downplays flaws on Windows Server because the default behavior of that system differs from other Windows versions. If you determine differently what constitutes a critical flaw, they argue, the Windows Server advantage is imagined.

Intellectual Property Indemnification

The oddest claim Ballmer makes concerns intellectual property indemnification. Here, Ballmer plays on the fear, uncertainty, doubt (FUD) principle: If you use Linux, you might be sued.

My Take on the Debate

My gut feeling about Linux is that it will provide an excellent upgrade solution for two main audiences: Those environments that run legacy, proprietary UNIX systems and want to take advantage of the commodity nature and performance of the x86 platform, and those environments that need what I call networking infrastructure services--DHCP, DNS, Web serving, file serving, and such. It's unlikely that most Windows shops will wholeheartedly jump ship and migrate to Linux across the board because doing so is typically extremely expensive in the long run.

Microsoft has done a lot of work to enable UNIX-to-Windows migrations and provide cross-platform interoperability with some non-UNIX legacy systems, such as mainframes. Although I don't feel that many UNIX shops ultimately will port their applications to Windows and not Linux, it's possible that some of them will move at least some of their infrastructure to Windows in the future.

Regardless, the simple answer is that we live in a heterogeneous world and will continue to do so. Rather than fling abuse at the other camp, I'd rather see Microsoft wake up to reality and learn to work with Linux. Increasingly, its customers are turning to Linux for good reasons. It's time Microsoft buried the hatchet.

IT Prolympics

If you've ever wondered how your IT skills stack up against your peers, here's your chance to find out. Enter Windows IT Pro's IT Prolympics. Download a study guide about Active Directory (AD) and Group Policy and then test your knowledge in a written exam and in a real-world V-lab skills test. It's fun, educational, and you could win a trip to TechEd 2005. Learn more at the following URL:


==== Sponsor: Free White Paper: High Availability for Windows Services ====
It is no stretch to say that Windows high availability must be a fundamental element in your short- and long-term strategic IT planning. This free white paper discusses the core issues surrounding Windows high availability, with a focus on business drivers and benefits. You'll learn about the current market solutions, technologies and real-world challenges including cost-benefit analyses. Plus, find out how to assess technical elements required in choosing a high availability solution, including the robustness of the technology, time-to-failover, and implementation difficulties. Download this white paper now!


==== 2. Hot Off the Press ====
by Paul Thurrott, [email protected]

With iPod Success, Apple Takes "Network Effect" from Microsoft During the epic Microsoft antitrust trial with the US Department of Justice (DOJ), witnesses and government experts spoke of the "network effect" that Microsoft enjoyed because of the success of its relatively low-price Windows products. Today, however, the company that's most obviously enjoying the benefits of the network effect is Apple Computer, whose iPod portable audio player now dominates an important emerging market. And, ironically, Apple's success with the iPod is coming at the expense of Microsoft and its partners, which have watched as competitor after competitor fail to make a dent in the iPod's armor. To read the entire story, visit the following URL:

==== Announcements ====
(from Windows IT Pro and its partners)

Enter to Win a $100 American Express Gift Card at the Secure Messaging Center
Stop wasting your valuable resources! Find out everything you need to know to secure your messaging environment, including information about antigen antivirus solutions, antispam solutions, and content-filtering. Access FAQs, free seminars, and the latest articles. Take the Instant Messaging survey for a chance to win a $100 gift card!

Are You Using Virtualization Technology? If So, You Could Be a Virtualization Hero!
Share your experiences using virtualization (aka virtual machine) products to solve IT and business problems. Enter the Windows IT Pro Virtualization Hero contest, and tell us how you used virtualization technology in innovative ways to benefit your business. Winners will receive a copy of Microsoft Virtual Server 2005. Also, you can post a comment in our Virtualization Technology blog, moderated by members of Microsoft's Virtual Server team. To enter the blog and for a link to the contest, click here:

Subscribe Now to Windows IT Pro with Exclusive Online Access!
Windows & .NET Magazine is now Windows IT Pro! Act now to get the November issue, which features a Linux primer for Windows administrators, the how-tos of making NTBackup work, and a checklist for Sarbanes-Oxley compliance. You'll save 30% off the cover price and receive exclusive subscriber-only access to our entire online library with your paid subscription! This is a limited-time offer, so click here to order today!

Get a Quick Reference Guide to the Latest Antispam Developments
A recent survey shows that spam is the number one pain point for IT pros, and spammers find new methods to avoid filters every day. Counter spam by learning the essentials for ensuring user productivity, increasing mail-server efficiency, decreasing storage requirements, managing bandwidth, and controlling TCO. Download this free, quick reference guide now!

~~~~ Hot Release: (Advertisement) Just Released >>> Free 86-page Server Spec Book ~~~~

This new 86-page guide from World Data Products is the definitive resource on processor, memory and storage specifications for Dell PowerEdge, HP/Compaq ProLiant, and IBM xSeries servers. A must for everyone involved in the design, installation and maintenance of servers. From World Data Products, the world-class provider of server, storage, networking and telecom solutions.
To order go to or call 800-553-0592

==== Instant Poll ====

Results of Previous Poll:
The voting has closed in Windows IT Pro's nonscientific Instant Poll for the question, "Can you access enterprise applications from your mobile computing device?" Here are the results from the 78 votes:
- 35%Yes
- 65% No

New Instant Poll:
The next Instant Poll question is, "Would you trust and use Internet-based voting?" Go to the Windows IT Pro home page and submit your vote for a) Yes, if third-party experts are hired to certify its security, b) Yes, but only after public scrutiny of the voting system, c) No, never, or d) I don't know.

==== 3. Resources ====

Featured Thread: Win XP Starts Up Automatically
Forum user Tobi360 has a Windows XP workstation that automatically boots up every morning at 7:00 A.M. He's checked for settings and software that might cause this reboot, but can nothing. If you can help, visit the following URL:

Tip: What's the difference between the Microsoft Virtual Server 2005 editions?
by John Savill,

Virtual Server 2005 comes in two editions: Standard and Enterprise. Both versions have the same functionality but support different numbers of processors. Standard Edition supports up to four processors, and Enterprise Edition supports up to 32 processors.

==== Events Central ====
(A complete Web and live events directory brought to you by Windows IT Pro: )

Securing Your Organization's Messaging Traffic
In this free Web seminar, security expert Randy Franklin Smith will take a high-level look at the current security trends in the industry, the emerging threats, and the threats that have become passe. Plus, you’ll learn about the commonly held misconceptions about security patches and which kinds of attacks companies are reporting in increased numbers. Register now!

==== 4. New and Improved ====
by Angie Brew, [email protected]

Identify and Patch Security Holes
GFI Software released GFI LANguard Network Security Scanner (N.S.S.) 5, a network security scanner that analyzes the OS and identifies potential security holes. The product features Scan Profiles that let administrators scan for open shares on workstations, security audit and password policies, machines missing a particular patch, or machines missing a particular service pack. GFI LANguard N.S.S. deploys missing patches or services packs and checks the GFI Web site for updates to the vulnerability database and the Microsoft patch database, then downloads any new vulnerabilities or patch information automatically. For pricing, contact GFI Software at 919-379-3397.

Test Installations Before Deployment
Wise Solutions released Wise Package Studio 5.1, application testing and deployment software. The product uses a structured process called enterprise software packaging to guide you through application preparation in logical steps. Preflight Deployment lets you test installations in your real-world environment to see if they will succeed or fail. Wise Package Studio features unique fingerprinting technology that ensures software applications on end-user systems are packaged and delivered through approved methods. The software can customize applications for Windows Mobile 2003-based Pocket PCs. For pricing, contact Wise Solutions at 734-456-2100.

Tell Us About a Hot Product and Get a T-Shirt!
Have you used a product that changed your IT experience by saving you time or easing your daily burden? Tell us about the product, and we'll send you a T-shirt if we write about the product in a future Windows IT Pro What's Hot column. Send your product suggestions with information about how the product has helped you to mailto:[email protected]


==== Contact Us ====

About the newsletter -- [email protected] About technical questions -- About product news -- [email protected] About your subscription -- [email protected] About sponsoring UPDATE -- [email protected]


This email newsletter is brought to you by Windows IT Pro, the leading publication for IT professionals deploying Windows and related technologies. Subscribe today!

View the Windows IT Pro Privacy policy at Windows IT Pro is a division of Penton Media, Inc. 221 East 29th Street, Loveland, CO 80538, Attention: Customer Service Department Copyright 2004, Penton Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

TAGS: Security
Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.