Exchange & Outlook UPDATE, Exchange Edition--Tooling Up for Exchange Migration

Subscribe to Windows IT Pro:


Don't miss out! Make sure your copy of Exchange and Outlook UPDATE isn't mistakenly blocked by antispam software. Add [email protected] to your list of allowed senders and contacts.


This email newsletter comes to you free and is supported by the following advertisers, which offer products and services in which you might be interested. Please take a moment to visit these advertisers' Web sites and show your support for Exchange & Outlook UPDATE.

Sherpa Software

Symantec Corporation


1. Commentary
- Tooling Up for Exchange Migration

2. Peer to Peer
- Instant Poll
- Featured Thread: Renaming an Exchange Mailbox
- Outlook Tip: Inserting a Link in a Contact

3. New and Improved
- View Your Email Server Performance from Anywhere

==== Sponsor: Sherpa Software====

PST and Mailbox Management Made Easy with Mail Attender

Having trouble accessing PST Files? Looking for an affordable email management solution? Mail Attender Enterprise automatically manages PST files (local/network), Public Folders and Mailboxes from a central location.

Enforce document retention policies to control storage, search and retrieve content, archive critical information, delete unnecessary emails and attachments, compact PST files, compress/zip large attachments, report on space utilization and collect statistics

Whether it's discovering PST files, mailbox management or trend reporting, Mail Attender will help fulfill your Exchange storage, management, and compliance needs. Download a FREE TRIAL today and instantly view statistics like total message/attachment count, size, and type across your entire Exchange information store!


Editor's note: Share Your Exchange Discoveries and Get $100
Share your Exchange Server and Outlook discoveries, comments, or problems and solutions for use in the Exchange & Outlook Administrator print newsletter's Reader to Reader column. Email your contributions (500 words or less) to [email protected] We edit submissions for style, grammar, and length. If we print your submission, you'll get $100.


==== 1. Commentary: Tooling Up for Exchange Migration ====
by Paul Robichaux, Exchange Editor, [email protected]

Last week, I briefly mentioned that Microsoft had released an updated version of the Application Analyzer 2006 for Lotus Domino (;amp;displaylang=en&familyid=D94C5719-570D-4ADB-B449-70E1E42CBFC5&displaylang=en ), and I promised to talk more about it this week. More generally, though, it's interesting to look at the state of the art and state of the market, for Exchange migration tools.

First, it's important to use the right vocabulary--or at least the same terms that Microsoft uses in the official documentation. If you move from some other messaging system (e.g., Lotus Notes or a UNIX POP3 server) to Exchange Server 2003, that's a migration. If you move from Exchange Server 5.5 to Exchange 2003, Microsoft also considers that a migration. However, if you move from Exchange 2000 Server to Exchange 2003, that's an upgrade. I'll stick with these definitions for the remainder of the column.

Microsoft has always offered some set of migration tools as part of the Exchange product. The Migration Wizard (migwiz.exe) in Exchange 5.5, for example, could migrate mail and calendar data from several foreign system types (including LDAP/IMAP systems, cc:Mail, Lotus Notes, and Novell GroupWise 5.x). Over time, Microsoft's commitment to shipping migration tools has waxed and waned; in Exchange 2003, the in-the-box tools include an updated version of migwiz and connectors to allow message, calendar, and public folder data interchange with selected versions of GroupWise and Notes. For example, the latest version of GroupWise is version 7.0, and the Microsoft GroupWise connector doesn't officially support that version (although I understand that it works fine). There are many third parties that offer migration tools for other messaging/calendaring systems; for example, Simpler-Webb offers tools to migrate from HP OpenMail, Samsung Contact, and Scalix, whereas Quest Software offers well-regarded tools for migrating from GroupWise and Notes.

For many migrations, it's enough to just move email and calendar data; mail-moving tools are sufficient for users migrating from Oracle Collaboration Suite, IMAP or POP-based systems, GroupWise, and a variety of lesser-known products. However, Notes migrations are a different animal because many Notes customers are also using collaborative applications built with Notes; although Exchange clearly offers a better messaging and calendaring system than Notes (particularly when you include the desktop client in the comparison), companies that have invested heavily in Notes application development quite rightly worry about preserving their application investments.

Microsoft's tack toward these customers is straightforward: The company has moved away from claims that migration is easy to a more nuanced position that admits the way things really are--some applications are harder to move than others. In addition, it has proposed a framework that classifies applications according to the amount of customization and embedded logic in the application; lightly customized applications or those with minimal embedded logic are obviously easier to move than large, heavily customized ones. (To see more about this methodology, see the blog for the collaboration tools team at Microsoft ( ). That's what the new Application Analyzer tool is for. It scans the applications in use on a set of Domino servers and reports back on which applications fall into which categories. As with any other automated tool that attempts to interpret code, its results still require human interpretation. (Oh, the stories I could tell about automated code analysis tools from the days when I wrote Ada compilers for a living!)

The missing piece in the migration story is moving the applications themselves to a new platform. There are several different ways to accomplish this, ranging from completely rewriting the application using the .NET Framework to writing a new front-end in .NET and exposing the existing data through the Component Object Model (COM) interfaces or by embedding Notes data and presentation logic in a SharePoint Web Part. Several companies make tools for moving Notes data (including document libraries) to SharePoint libraries or Exchange public folders, but as yet, the market for tools that attempt to convert the code is still fairly small in scope, with only a few vendors even making the attempt. I expect this situation to change as the battle between Microsoft and IBM intensifies; IBM is pushing Notes, and its successor, Workplace Collaboration Services, as a future-proof way to protect existing investments, whereas Microsoft is countering with the argument that its platform offers better technology, a lower total cost, and more functionality to boot.

Of course, in the Exchange world, most of the attention around migration is focused on moving from Exchange 5.5 to Exchange 2003. I had a great meeting with a customer this week that I think exemplified the *right* way to prepare for such a migration. Next week I'll tell you why I think so.


==== Sponsor: Symantec Corporation ====

Learn the commonalities across multiple compliance regulations and standards to optimize your environment and save time and money.


==== Events and Resources ====
(A complete Web and live events directory brought to you by Windows IT Pro: )

DevConnections Europe Early Bird Special extended through 15 March!Four conferences for the price of one! Don't miss DevConnections Europe--coming to Nice, France, 24-27 April 2006.

Use virtualization technology to leverage your IT assets, address critical business needs, and get the most out of your existing hardware with Windows Server 2003 R2. Live Event: April 4; 12:00 pm EST

Learn the best ways to manage your email security (and fight spam) using a variety of solutions and tips.

Efficiently replicate file changes across WANS without worrying about your remote server backups using the improved Distributed File System in WSS R2. Live Event: March 14; 12:00 pm EST

SPECIAL PODCAST OFFER: Expert Ben Smith describes the benefits of using server virtualization to make computers more efficient.

==== Featured White Papers ====

Manage your data growth, improve reliability and speed data recovery using continuous data protection.

~~~~ Hot Spot ~~~~

Align compliance with business efficiency, and learn how fax-document management plays a role in your strategy.

==== 2. Peer to Peer ====

Instant Poll
The next Exchange & Outlook Instant Poll question is "What's the biggest messaging-security threat your company faces?" Go to and submit your vote for a) Virus/worm attacks via email attachments, b) Virus/worm attacks via IM, c) Spam (e.g., phishing, scams), or d) Spam (e.g., phishing, scams).

Featured Thread: Renaming an Exchange Mailbox
A forum reader wants to know how to rename an Exchange Server 2003 mailbox. . Join the discussion at
Outlook Tip: Inserting a Link in a Contact
by Sue Mosher, [email protected]

Q: In an Outlook contact record, how can I insert a link that points to a folder on my hard disk?
Find the answer (and links to more great tips) at

==== Announcements ====
(from Windows IT Pro and its partners)

Windows IT Pro Magazine Article Library - access available
Sign up for a Monthly Online Pass and get INSTANT access to all articles, tools, and helpful resources published on, including exclusive subscriber-only content. You'll get 24/7 access to the full Windows IT article library (includes over 9,000 focused articles) and get the latest digital issue of Windows IT Pro Magazine delivered right to your inbox. Sign up now:

Windows IT Pro Magazine--SAVE 58%
Windows IT Pro is a must-have in 2006! Subscribe now and plug into the largest independent Windows IT community in the world. Along with loads of how-to articles, time-saving advice, and expert tips and solutions, you'll gain exclusive access to the entire online Windows IT Pro article library FREE. This is a limited-time offer, so order now:

==== 3. New and Improved ==== by Blake Eno, [email protected]

View Your Email Server Performance from Anywhere
MXToolBox released MXWatch Email Performance Index, a tool that shows the health and performance of your email systems by graphically comparing the speed at which your email servers communicate with one another. MXWatch then lets you compare your server's current performance to past performance. Because MXWatch posts its results to its Web site, you can also view email server performance of other organizations to see whether they're having similar performance problems. For more information, contact MXToolBox at 512-637-8762.


~~~~ Contact Us ~~~~

About the newsletter -- [email protected] About technical questions -- About product news -- [email protected] About your subscription -- [email protected] About sponsoring UPDATE -- [email protected]


This email newsletter is brought to you by Exchange & Outlook Administrator, the leading publication for IT professionals managing, securing, optimizing, and migrating Exchange and Outlook. Subscribe today!

Manage Your Account
You are subscribed as %%$email%%

You are receiving this email message because you subscribed to this newsletter on our Web site. To unsubscribe, click the unsubscribe link:

View the Windows IT Pro Privacy policy at Windows IT Pro a division of Penton Media Inc. 221 East 29th Street, Loveland, CO 80538, Attention: Customer Service Department Copyright 2006, Penton Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.